bthat was India, nearly 400 million people, was divided into
bscores of languages, religions, and sects. But, in particular, it
bwas the broad category of Hindus versus Muslims that made the
boriginal British decision to grant the country independence im-
bpossible. In 1942 the British had proposed freedom for India
bwith a pledge by the new country “for the protection of social
band religious minorities.”
bThe Muslims adamantly refused to rely on this promise.
bThey made up only some 22 percent of the total population and
bdid not trust the 68 percent Hindu majority. The reason? Differ-
bence; major and fundamental difference. Under Muhammad Ali Jin-
bnah, they won the battle to partition the subcontinent into a
bHindu “India” and a Muslim “Pakistan.” But that clear under-
bstanding of the impossibility of living together in one state did
bnot solve the problem of the minorities who would be living in a
bsmaller version of an unpartitioned state. The nineteen million
bHindus and Sikhs who would now become minority citizens in
ba fiercely nationalist Islamic Pakistan began nervously to con-
bsider the resentment that the Muslims, mostly poor farmers, had
bborne against the Hindu merchants and storekeepers.
bIn turn, Choudharry Rahmat Ali, founder of the Pakistan
bnational movement, wrote: “To leave our minorities in Hindu
blands is. . . to forget the tragic fate that overwhelmed our mi-
bnorities which—in more favorable times—. . . we left in Sicily,
bItaly, France, Portugal, Spain, Austria, and Hungary. Where
bare they now?”
bThe reality was not long in coming: massacres and com-
bmunal riots. In the Punjab, where Muslims made up 57 percent
bof the total population. In Lahore and Amritsar, mobs, knives,
band fires swept the cities. By June 23, 1947, at least 3,200 people
bhad been killed in the Punjab alone. The Hindus and Sikhs
bbegan to flee. By July a quarter of a million Hindus had fled to
bIndia. Panic spread to other parts of the subcontinent.
bHindus began to flee in terror from East Bengal. By 1948,
b100,000 had run from Pakistan’s capital of Karachi—the fear of
bminority status, the fear of being strangers, the desire for sanc-
btuary among their own people. The most horrible kind of
bmurder and looting took place. It has been estimated that
b200,000 people were killed in the Punjab alone. To quote one
bobserver, “There was a positive lust for blood. . . . Casualties
b